SOIL, Designer Soil: From Rainforests to the Prairie
By Cooper-Hewitt National Design Museum, April 5, 2010
- Middle School
- Social Studies
Soil is one of the most important building blocks for ecosystems around the world, from the rainforests of South America to the prairies of the North American Midwest. Soil consists of three primary components: sand, clay and organic matter (or humus). The amount of each of these components, determines the type of soil and the kinds of vegetation and animal life that can thrive with this soil. In many ways, the type of soil affects the entire dynamic of an ecosystem and the life around it.Sand, clay and humus form the various types of soil that support life on our planet. Each gram of fertile soil contains hundreds of billions of bacteria – hundreds of thousands of fungi and algae, and tens of thousands of protozoa. Soil is created over centuries through a process of decomposition and nutrient cycles. The health of the soil around the globe and in your community is an increasingly important concern. From erosion to contamination threats, the health of our soil affects food safety, cost and a vast quantity of other crucial health factors. Consider also that it takes roughly a millennium to build an inch or two of soil; yet it takes less that forty years, on average, to strip an inch of soil by farming in ways that are more focused on yield than on sustaining fertility.
Designers today are paying more attention to the field of soil science as they consider architecture and products in relationship to sustainability and site specificity. How we design in relationship to our local landscape and the soil that makes up this landscape is therefore a crucial design challenge. In this lesson, students will learn some of the fundamentals of soil science. This understanding will be used to help students solve design challenges based on location, soil type and local ecosystem criteria. This lesson will also compliment US History lessons about the role of agriculture and soil in the United States, using historical examples as reference and a starting point for ideas and dialogue.
Common Core Literacy for Other Subjects
Strand Reading for Science and Technical Subjects Grades 6-8 RST.6-8.3. Follow precisely a multistep procedure when carrying out experiments, taking measurements, or performing technical tasks. RST.6-8.7. Integrate quantitative or technical information expressed in words in a text with a version of that information expressed visually
Strand Writing for History/Social Studies, Science, and Technical Subjects Grades 6-8 WHST.6-8.2. Write informative/explanatory texts, including the narration of historical events, scientific procedures/ experiments, or technical processes.
Common Core English Language Arts Strand Speaking and Listening Grade 6-8
SL.6-8.1. Engage effectively in a range of collaborative discussions (one-on-one, in groups, and teacherled) with diverse partners on grade 6 topics, texts, and issues, building on others’ ideas and expressing their own clearly.
World History Level III (Grade 7-8)
Era 1 - The Beginnings of Human Society
Standard 2. Understands the processes that contributed to the emergence of agricultural societies around the world
Benchmark 1. Understands immediate and long-term impacts and influences of early agricultural communities (e.g., areas in Southwest Asia and the Nile valley where early farming communities first appeared, the effect of new tools and other objects on early farming settlements, whether fishing was considered a nomadic or agricultural way of life) Benchmark 2. Understands influences on the spread of agricultural communities (e.g., how local needs and conditions affected food plant domestication and world-wide patterns of settlement)
Era 3 - Classical Traditions, Major Religions, and Giant Empires, 1000 BCE-300 CE
Standard 10. Understands how early agrarian civilizations arose in Mesoamerica Benchmark 2. Understands characteristics of Olmec agriculture (e.g., the social and environmental impacts, and the methods of Olmec agriculture; how farming in Mesoamerica differed from that of other agrarian societies in the ancient world)
Era 4 - Expanding Zones of Exchange and Encounter, 300-1000 CE
Standard 16. Understands the development of agricultural societies and new states in tropical Africa and Oceania Benchmark 1. Understands influences on state-building in West Africa Benchmark 2. Understands the establishment of agricultural societies on the Pacific Islands and New ZealandEra 7 - An Age of Revolutions, 1750-1914 Standard 33. Understands the causes and consequences of the agricultural and industrial revolutions from 1700 to 1850 Benchmark 4. Understands the importance and consequences of new technologies (e.g., seed drill, crop rotation, stock breeding, three piece iron) in the agricultural revolution
Geography Level III (Grade 6-8)
Benchmark 4. Knows changes that have occurred over time in ecosystems in the local region (e.g., natural wetlands on a flood plain being replaced by farms, farmlands on a flood plain being replaced by housing developments) Benchmark 5. Knows the potential impact of human activities within a given ecosystem on the carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen cycles (e.g., the role of air pollution in atmospheric warming or the growing of peas and other legumes, which supply their own nitrogen and do not deplete the soil)
Science Level III (Grade 6-8)
Standard 2. Understands Earth's composition and structure Benchmark 2. Knows how land forms are created through a combination of constructive and destructive forces (e.g., constructive forces such as crustal deformation, volcanic eruptions, and deposition of sediment; destructive forces such as weathering and erosion)
Benchmark 3. Knows components of soil and other factors that influence soil texture, fertility, and resistance to erosion (e.g., plant roots and debris, bacteria, fungi, worms, rodents)
- Students will learn core fundamentals of soil science
- Students will better understand the role of soil in their local region
- Students will use design thinking strategies to develop solutions to major environmental and land use issues
- Students will understand how soil relates to major themes in US History
Design for a Living World Connection
Look at Abott Miller’s Plywood Furniture project that uses Forest Stewardship Council certified wood. How does a more sustainably harvested forest improve soil quality?
Slow Money by Woody Tasch
Cooper-Hewitt, 2010 National Design Triennial
See Soil Lamp
Sand, vermiculite, compost, cardboard, paper, paper towel tubes, rubber bands, string, tape, glue, shallow trays
- Soil - A mixture of sand and organic material, used to support plant growth
- Humus - partially decomposed organic matter; the organic component of soil
- Carbon Cycle - the organic circulation of carbon from the atmosphere into organisms and back again
- Nutrient Cycle - The passage of a nutrient or element through an ecosystem
- Soil Science - the study of soil as a natural resource on the surface of the earth including soil formation, classification and mapping
- NPK - The chemical symbols for Nitrogen (N), Phosphorous (P), and Potassium (K),an abbreviation that may be used in denoting the relative proportions of these - elements as ingredients of a fertilizer.
- Fertilizer - any substance such as manure or a mixture of nitrates used to make soil more fertile
- Soil Erosion - The washing away of soil by the flow of water or wind.
Introduction to Soil! (Review, 15 minutes)
To begin your lesson, take some time to discuss and introduce the concept of soil science – the study of soil. According to the USDA, there are over 50,000 different varieties of soil in the United States alone! The type of soil is dependent upon the soil’s parent material, topography, climate, the organisms in and around the soil, and the amount of time it takes for these to all interact. Since these characteristics vary worldwide, soil profiles also vary worldwide.
The above map of the United States illustrates just a few of the diverse soil types that can be found across the country.Soil starts with a process called weathering. Physical and chemical weathering processes erode parent material like rocks into mineral particles. These materials are then transported by volcanoes, wind, water, ice, and waves, which deposit these minerals around the landscape. The minerals are then influenced by gravity, and upon deposition create landforms from which soil formation begins.
There are a couple of important minerals to consider:
- Sand: The major mineral in sand is called quartz and it is composed of silica and oxygen (SiO2).
- Clay: Silicates, mica, iron, and aluminum hydrous-oxide minerals are found in clay. The silicate clay group is primarily located in the mid-latitudes, while the iron and aluminum clays are found in the tropic zones.
There are many other concepts you can expand on here including: nutrient cycling, soil chemistry, geology, rock formations, etc.
To help students better understand soil, you can lead some simple hands-on activities and experiments in the classroom.
Example: Building Soil
Set up an activity for student design teams to make different soil profiles. Each team can represent a different part of the world. Asia, North America, Europe and South America for instance. Supply students with the three main ingredients for soil (sand, clay and compost) and a beaker of water.
Team Asia – 1 cup of clay, ¼ cup of compost and ½ cup of sand
Team South America – 1 cup of compost, ½ cup of clay and 1 cup of sand
Team North America – 1 cup of compost, ¼ cup of sand, ¼ cup of clay
Team Europe – ½ cup of compost, ½ cup of sand and ¼ cup of clay
Assemble all the elements at proper ratios and add a splash of water to each.
Soils for Greenroofs
Greenroofs are vegetated roof covers, with plants taking the place of typical roofing material like shingles or tiles. Greenroofs help to reduce energy costs by keeping in heat and air conditioning, while providing a habitat for insects, animals and birds, helping to improve air quality and collect water from storms. The soils or “mediums” used to grow plants on a greenroof are usually much different than the potting soil mix or soil you would find in your backyard.
Many organizations are designing special kinds of greenroof soils that will work better for the conditions of a building. One major issue is weight. The weight of the greenroof is a concern for any structure. Because of this, greenroof soils are lightweight and are able to retain water much more easily than normal soils. The thin layer in which they must be applied to roof toops requires that they be extremely absorbant. The Gaia Institute has developed a soil that works great for these conditions called GaiaSoil™. The main ingredient in GaiaSoil™ is a non-toxic recycled expanded polystyrene foam coated with an organic pectin (pectin is the main ingredient in gelatin), and mixed with high-quality finished compost (a fertilizer for plants). http://www.thegaiainstitute.org/Gaia/Home.html
This kind of soil avoids additional reinforcement on the roof of the building, allows a more diverse plant selection, and can capture stormwater easily, making it possible for greater soil depth and easier transport.
Soil in Relationship to History and the Environment (Investigate 10 minutes)
Now that students have a basic understanding of soil, discuss the role of soil in relationship to a current history lesson you may be conducting. Ask students to think about how soil affected the development of agriculture.
During the expansion of the thirteen colonies and into the Civil War Era, soil type and quality had a lot of influence on the formation of cities, towns and what kinds of industries flourished in a certain area. Include lessons about local industry in the United States. In the south, for instance, soils can be more clay-like – but the climate is better for growing crops more months out of the year than in New England.
Was your region of the country heavy in agriculture or mining? How did the soil type affect what kinds of structures were built and used throughout history? Bring up relevant examples and discuss as a class.
After talking about some historical influences, discuss some of the major environmental challenges associated with soil quality in the past and currently:
- Agriculture and farming – Industrial farming and monoculture crops rapidly deplete the soil of nutrients, which are replaced each year with chemical fertilizers. The soil is then damaged beyond repair taking upwards of 50-75 years to restore.
- Brownfields and Superfund sites – Many areas of the United States have been contaminated because of their proximity to chemical waste sites or industrial runoff. These sites have been designated Brownfield or Superfund sites because of the degree of toxicity that remains in the soil – commonly the site of oil, chemical or biological spills.
- Erosion and mudslides – Development for housing/buildings have caused unprecedented amount of erosion and mudslides to occur around the world. Removing plant life loosens the soil, making it easy for wind, water or other forces to erode the soil or cause a mudslide.
As an example of innovative design using soil, reference the 2010 National Design Triennial’s entry the Soil Lamp:
Soil Lamp - A number of designers today are integrating objects with alternative means of clean power to create self-contained, self-sustaining systems. For Dutch designer Marieke Staps, the power source is mud. Her Soil Lamp makes use of the metabolism of biological life in dirt to produce enough energy to power a small LED light. The soil, enclosed in cells containing zinc and copper, acts as an electrolyte—an electrically conductive medium—and requires only a simple splash of water to keep it from drying out. The more cells there are, the more electricity can be generated. Staps’ design and naming of the Soil Lamp celebrates the transparency and simplicity of its process: the earth battery is housed in a clear bulbous base, with power carried along a thin conductor leading to a bare bulb. Exposing the possibilities of another source of abundant, renewable energy, the lamp serves to invigorate future innovation for small, contained power systems.
Design Challenge: Saving Our Soils…! (Frame/ReFrame)
After discussing some potential challenges and historical connections, talk about some of the recent solutions being developed by designers to address soil conservation and quality:
- Remediation Techniques – Many scientists and designers are thinking of innovative ways to remediate (or improve) soil quality. One method is Mycoremediation or the use of mushrooms to absorb toxins in certain soil types. Oyster mushrooms are commonly used in oil spills for instance, accumulating the oil in a metabolic process. Other materials like wetlands plants and other hyper accumulators can help to remediate soils naturally.
- Conservation/Preservation – A straightforward technique to preserving soils and their quality is open space preservation and conservation of sensitive lands.
- Organic/Sustainable Farming – Sustainable farming techniques that reduce or eliminate the use of pesticides, fertilizers and other harmful chemicals used to “enrich” soils can improve soil fertility manyfold.
- Composting – Composting, or the process of recycling organic wastes like dead leaves, food scraps and other wastes into a fertilizer can be used to naturally restore nutrients to soil.
Now its time for a design challenge! In this exercise, encourage students to use design thinking to problem-solve a scenario presented to each team. The scenario will setup a design problem and students will work as a team to develop a solution based on their knowledge of soil science.
Scenario One: The mayor has asked you to look into fixing up a former industrial site along a major river that cuts through downtown. He wants to turn the site into a park. The site used to be home to the Miller-Smith Corporation. Unfortunately the site is now designated a Brownfield site because of chemical runoff that has accumulated in the soil. What can you do to fix the site and what kind of a park would you design?
Scenario Two: A developer wants you to be the lead architect on a new housing development. The development site is partly on a steep slope with lots of sandy soil. Design a house that could be constructed on the site that would adapt to the soil and the steep conditions.
Scenario Three: A big farm recently went out of business. This left over 40 acres of land that had grown just one crop – lots of corn! The soil now looks kind of orange and dusty. When the wind picks up a lot of the soil blows away. You’ve been asked to divide the land into 20 smaller farms. What kind of a farm would you design and how would you fix the soil?
Scenario Four: You live down by the beach. Every year more and more condos are being built along the shoreline. You’ve noticed that the beach keeps getting smaller each year, but still more houses are built. As a town planner, you’ve been asked to help save some of the beach from eroding into the ocean. What kind of conservation plan would you come up with? How would you save the beach and what would a preservation site look like?
Sketch and Brainstorm (Generate, 10-15 minutes)
After presenting scenarios to each design team, ask them to brainstorm and create sketches that respond to their situation.
Model Making (Edit and Develop, 25-30 Minutes)
After each design team generates sketches, provide students with modeling materials. Ask each team to develop 3D representation of their design with the corresponding soil type as a base.
After each team completes their model, share your design solutions as a class. Tie in historical and environmental discussions previously held in class and encourage students to talk about their designs from the perspective of the soil. (Share and Evaluate)
- What are the biggest challenges to designing soil for an environment that has been damaged?
- What do you think is the biggest strength of your design? What unique aspect of your work makes it exceptional and successful?
- Based on your knowledge of geography and scientific topics such as volcanoes, plant growth and decomposition, why do you think soil types vary from continent to continent?
Enrichment Extension Activities
Differentiation for Elementary School:
- For younger students, keep the Introduction to Soil discussion focused on the soil and agricultural history of your region. Use lots of hands-on experiments and soil examples to explore different types of soil. Show the students how adding different compounds (clay, sand, compost) can help the soil change to the ideal profile of your region.
- In the Design Challenge, focus on scenario three: fixing a farm's soil. Each group can brainstorm ideas and experiment with different soil compounds (clay, sand, compost) to reach their desired soil. They can share their findings with the class.
- Older students can choose a topic related to soil to research in depth (environmental challenges, history of local agriculture, greenroofs, soil chemistry, etc.) and present their findings to the class.
- For each Design Challenge scenerio, find an individual that can act as the "client," which the group can interview. Their designs will need to take into account the client's specific needs and constraints.